State audit ties sheriff’s office failures to New Orleans jailbreak
A new legislative audit says weak staffing, missed security checks, questionable spending and more than 1,300 potential payroll overlap cases helped create the conditions around last year’s Orleans Justice Center escape.
NEW ORLEANS (WVUE) - A sweeping state audit says failures in staffing, security checks, spending oversight and deputy accountability at the Orleans Parish Sheriff’s Office helped create the conditions surrounding last year’s jailbreak at the Orleans Justice Center.
The Louisiana Legislative Auditor said the review was launched after 10 inmates escaped from the jail on May 16, 2025, and examined OPSO operations from 2022 through 2025.
Read: Take a look inside the house where Derrick Groves was found
Among its findings, the audit said OPSO staff did not routinely conduct required jail inspections and security checks. During the week of May 11 through May 17, 2025 — the week of the escape — auditors found staff documented inspections during only 206 of 322 required shifts, or 64%, and documented only 2,700 of 9,072 required security checks, or 29.8%.
The report said performance varied sharply by pod. In one example, only 14 of 336 required checks on Pod 1C were documented, or 4.2%.
Auditors also found the inspection form for Pod 1D, the pod from which the inmates escaped, was not filled out for either shift on May 15, 2025, the day before the escape, or for the first shift the morning the escape was discovered.
The audit said deputies may have violated state law by being paid to work at OPSO during the same hours they were reported as working off-duty details. Auditors identified 1,316 instances involving 179 deputies where times appeared to overlap. In 714 of those instances, the overlap exceeded 30 minutes.
The report said those weak detail controls could worsen staffing issues inside the jail because deputies who are supposed to be working there may not actually be present when scheduled.
Beyond staffing, auditors said OPSO expenditures rose 38.9%, from $59.1 million in 2022 to $82.1 million in 2024, while payroll costs climbed 55.1%, from $30.1 million in 2022 to $46.7 million in 2025, in part because of overtime. Meanwhile, the inmate population increased 46.6%, while the number of employees assigned to monitor inmates in the jail increased just 2.6%.
The audit also criticized what it described as discretionary and potentially improper spending, including at least $19,411 in late fees, interest and finance charges, and at least $14,030 in petty cash purchases that auditors said did not appear to serve a public purpose. Those purchases included food and balloons for holiday parties, a barbecue and gift cards.
Auditors further said OPSO appears to have violated Louisiana law and the state constitution in some procurement and payment practices and faulted the agency for using antiquated, disconnected financial systems that cannot generate basic financial reports efficiently.
In a written response included in the audit, Sheriff Susan Hutson agreed with some recommendations but disputed others, saying parts of the report lacked context, were contradictory and could mislead readers. Hutson also said staffing shortages and low pay remain major problems and acknowledged that burnout has contributed to shortcuts inside the jail.
The audit recommends that OPSO improve security checks, tighten controls on off-duty details, upgrade its accounting systems and strengthen contract, purchasing and payment procedures.
See a spelling or grammar error in our story? Click Here to report it. Please include the headline.
Subscribe to the Fox 8 YouTube channel.
Copyright 2026 WVUE. All rights reserved.
