Judge puts off ruling in court battle over LGBT-rights protectio - WAFB 9 News Baton Rouge, Louisiana News, Weather, Sports

Judge puts off ruling in court battle over LGBT-rights protection order

Gov. John Bel Edwards and Attorney General Jeff Landry (Source: WAFB) Gov. John Bel Edwards and Attorney General Jeff Landry (Source: WAFB)
BATON ROUGE, LA (WAFB) -

A decision in the court case between the Louisiana governor and attorney general will not come until at least later this week.

After eight hours of testimony Tuesday, Judge Todd Hernandez asked both sides to submit follow-up written arguments in the case regarding Gov. John Bel Edward’s anti-discrimination executive order by Friday.

AG Jeff Landry, a Republican, sued the Democratic governor over the executive order. Signed by the governor in April, it requires that most state contracts include protections for members of the LGBT community.

The governor’s office - arguing that the AG was overstepping his authority - asked the judge to define the AG’s power in state government.

The AG’s office has blocked dozens of legal contracts that contain the clause. No other state agencies or vendors have objected to the executive order, according to Scott Johnson, a lawyer for the Division of Administration.  

RELATED:  Feud between La. governor, AG continues 8 months after both take office

Before Tuesday’s hearing, Landry had called the order unconstitutional and claimed the governor is effectively making state law. Several anti-discrimination bills failed to gain traction at the Capitol in the spring. 

"Gov. Edwards has done precisely done the same thing that Gov. Edwards complained that Gov. Jindal did and that is exceed his authority as the chief executive officer," said Elizabeth Murrill, a member of the civil division in the AG’s office.

In court Tuesday, however, the AG’s office, instead, focused much of its argument on the contents of the executive order itself. The office said it had been blocking contracts specifically due to the protections based on "gender identity" included in the order. One lawyer for the AG even suggested that if the governor agreed to remove those two words from the order, the case could be over and they could all go home.

The AG’s legal team called a human resource officer and an attorney to the witness stand who suggested that "gender identity" was an "ambiguous" term that could be burdensome and create legal problems for employers. Matthew Block, special counsel for the governor’s office, pointed out that the AG’s office has approved other contracts including language that complies with federal executive orders protecting people based on gender identity.

The governor’s office has said the AG is simply playing politics and is holding up state work in the process by blocking dozens of contracts from being finalized.

"The grab of authority that the attorney general has done with regards to state contracts and state legal matters is just simply beyond his authority," Block said. "I think the evidence showed that."

Block defended the executive order saying it is "lawful" and "good policy for the state," as it provides protections that do not exist in state law that ensure that employers cannot fire or discriminate against transgender and gay employees.

The implications of the case extend beyond just the feud between the two Louisiana officials, however.

Two weeks ago, the House Appropriations Committee held up contracts for state employee health benefits because of the LGBT protection clause. If those contracts are not approved by the legislature, however, thousands stand to lose their health benefits.

House Appropriations Chairman Cameron Henry, R-Metairie, said many on the committee had concerns about the "gender identity" part of the order. Speaking in court, Henry said he also felt that approving the contracts with the clause would concede the lawmaking power of the legislature to the executive branch.

Copyright 2016 WAFB. All rights reserved.

  • Trending StoriesTrending StoriesMore>>

  • College student arrested; tried to trade chicken alfredo, Sprite for sex

    College student arrested; tried to trade chicken alfredo, Sprite for sex

    Wednesday, December 13 2017 3:38 PM EST2017-12-13 20:38:04 GMT

    Youngstown State University student Albert Maruna was caught red-handed and arrested this week after he allegedly attempted to have sex with a 15-year-old boy, who turned out to be an undercover officer.  

    More >>

    Youngstown State University student Albert Maruna was caught red-handed and arrested this week after he allegedly attempted to have sex with a 15-year-old boy, who turned out to be an undercover officer.  

    More >>
  • Roy Moore responds after Senate loss to Doug Jones

    Roy Moore responds after Senate loss to Doug Jones

    Wednesday, December 13 2017 10:58 PM EST2017-12-14 03:58:33 GMT
    (Source: Moore campaign)(Source: Moore campaign)

    Roy Moore has released a statement following his loss to Senator-elect Doug Jones in Tuesday's election.  Moore released a video to the people of Alabama. The transcript is below: Tomorrow, my wife and I will celebrate our 32nd wedding anniversary. I want to thank her and all my family, for standing with me through this long and arduous campaign. And of course, I want to thank all of you who have stood with me in this very important battle for the future of our country. We ...

    More >>

    Roy Moore has released a statement following his loss to Senator-elect Doug Jones in Tuesday's election.  Moore released a video to the people of Alabama. The transcript is below: Tomorrow, my wife and I will celebrate our 32nd wedding anniversary. I want to thank her and all my family, for standing with me through this long and arduous campaign. And of course, I want to thank all of you who have stood with me in this very important battle for the future of our country. We ...

    More >>
  • Dan Johnson: KY State Rep. kills himself in Bullitt County

    Dan Johnson: KY State Rep. kills himself in Bullitt County

    Wednesday, December 13 2017 11:29 PM EST2017-12-14 04:29:43 GMT

    Kentucky state representative "Pope" Dan Johnson has committed suicide, days after a report surfaced alleging he assaulted a teenage girl in 2013.

    More >>

    Kentucky state representative "Pope" Dan Johnson has committed suicide, days after a report surfaced alleging he assaulted a teenage girl in 2013.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly